Panhandling & Free Expression

Many local officials tend to believe that panhandlers are detrimental to local businesses and tourism and, as such, it is no surprise that there have been many efforts to ban begging. While local governments keep trying to craft laws to pass constitutional muster, their efforts have generally proven futile in the face of the First Amendment. While the legal questions are addressed by courts, there remains the moral question of whether the banning of panhandling can be morally justified.

The obvious starting point for a moral argument for banning panhandling is a utilitarian approach. As noted above, local officials generally want to have such bans because they believe panhandlers can be bad for local businesses and tourism in general. For example, if potential customers are accosted by scruffy and unwashed panhandlers on the streets around businesses, then they are less likely to patronize those businesses. As another example, if a city gets a reputation for being awash in beggars who annoy tourists with their pleas for cash, then tourism is likely to decline. From the perspective of the business owners and the local officials, these effects would have negative value that would outweigh the benefits to the panhandlers of being able to ask for money. There is presumably also utility in encouraging panhandlers to move away to other locations, thus removing the financial and social cost of having panhandlers. If this utilitarian calculation is accurate, then banning panhandling would be morally acceptable. Of course, if the calculation is not correct and such a ban would do more harm than good, then the ban would be morally wrong.

A second utilitarian argument is the safety argument. While panhandlers generally do not engage in violence (they, after all, are asking for money and not trying to rob people), it has been claimed that they do present a safety risk. The standard concern is that by panhandling in or near traffic, they put themselves and others in danger. If this is true, then banning panhandling would be the right thing to do.  If, however, the alleged harm does not justify the ban, then it would be morally unacceptable.

There is also the obvious reply that any safety concerns could be addressed by having laws that forbid people from obstructing the flow of traffic and being a danger to themselves and others. Presumably many such laws exist in various localities. There is also the concern that the safety argument would need to be applied consistently to all such allegedly risky behavior around traffic, such as people engaging in political campaigns or street side advertising.

It is also easy enough to advance a utilitarian argument in favor of panhandling that is based on the harm that could be done by restricting the panhandlers’ freedom of expression and activity. Following Mill’s classic argument, as long as panhandlers are not harming people with their panhandling, then it would be wrong to limit their freedom to engage in this behavior. This is on the condition that the panhandling is, at worst, merely annoying and does not involve threatening behavior or harassment.

It could be objected that panhandling does cause harm—as noted above, the presence of panhandlers could harm local businesses. People can also regard panhandling as an infringement on their freedom to not be bothered in public. While this does have some appeal, this justification of a panhandling ban would also justify banning any public behavior people found annoying or that had some perceived impact on local businesses. This could include public displays of expression, political campaigning, preaching in public and many other behaviors that should not be banned. In short, the problem is that there is not something distinct enough to panhandling that would allow it to be banned without also justifying the ban of other activities. To simply ban it because it is panhandling would seem to solve this problem, but would not. After all, if an activity can be justly banned because it is that activity, then this would apply to any activity. After all, every activity is the activity it is.

Those who prefer an alternative to utilitarian calculations can easily defend panhandling against proposed bans by appealing to a right of free expression and behavior that is not based on utility. If people do have the moral right to free expression, then reasons would need to be advanced that would be strong enough to warrant violating this right. As noted above, an appeal could be made to the rights of businesses and the rights of other people to avoid being annoyed. However, the right to not be annoyed does not seem to trump the right of expression until the annoyance becomes significant. As such, a panhandler does have the right to annoy a person by asking for money, but if it crosses over into actual harassment, then this would be handled by the fact that people do not have a right to harassment.

In the case of businesses, while they do have a right to engage in free commerce, they do not have a right to expect people to behave in ways that are conducive to their business. If, for example, people found it offensive to have runners running downtown and decided to take their business elsewhere, this would not warrant a runner ban. But, if runners were blocking access to the businesses by running around the entrances, then the owners’ rights would be being violated. Likewise, if panhandlers are disliked by people and they decide to take their business elsewhere, this does not violate the rights of the businesses. But, if panhandlers started harassing people and blocking access to the businesses, then this would violate the rights of the owners.

 

 

My Amazon Author Page

My Paizo Page

My DriveThru RPG Page

Follow Me on Twitter

Leave a comment ?

20 Comments.

  1. Karen Lankford

    One significant difference between panhandling and other forms of free expression is that panhandling is an economic activity. Street peddlers typically must obtain licenses and are restricted from selling items directly in front of property tax paying businesses. Panhandles are not regulated. It could be argued that panhandlers are competing with local businesses for customer’s dollars. While this argument would not permit a complete ban on panhandling, it might justify restricting panhandling locations. If people give their money to panhandles or stay away from shopping districts because of them, the city could lose vital tax revenue to provide necessary city services.

  2. Kevin Henderson

    In more open, large area cities panhandlers are predominately at street corners where population flux, i.e. automobiles, tends to be high. Commerce is so spread out in suburbs panhandling becomes inefficient. Likewise affluent neighborhoods which have less density and tend towards geographically niche positions rarely see panhandlers.

    It might be interesting to think about where panhandlers are almost certainly never going to be found and consider what qualities of that portion of society can be replicated in other patches of society where panhandlers are almost certainly found.

  3. That is an interesting approach to the problem. The counter would probably be that the panhandlers are not offering a service or product, they are merely asking for money. But, as you said, the involvement of money could be used to contend that it is still an economic activity and thus subject to business regulation.

  4. Panhandlers who intrude into wealthy neighborhoods presumably are dealt with by the police at the behest of the wealthy. I’ve been hassled by the police for merely running through wealthy areas on “public” roads, so I can imagine what a panhandler would experience. Or perhaps they have a harder time reaching the affluent areas relative to city centers.

  5. Stomp, tap, tap,que d’entendre le little boy nufactured golf course rapide, claquant la porte a été ouverte nufactured have,a multi functional couru chez united nations garçon d’environ dix ans, habillé, belle apparence, ressemble not peu a simple matter et honnête, mais vu son round visage, minces sourcils sous le drame TV gush Chua Chua Dieu, noir et blanc, arrêter nufactured trembler comme des raisins noirs comme des globes oculaires. Je sens qu’il ya cuando peu

  6. Bow riders étaient plusieurs vagues nufactured boulon tiré Mongolie, pensait la tâche s’av’e rrtre très facile, juste être en mesure d’effacer les autres tours côté-le-feu, mais maintenant, les choses semblent au-delà nufactured toutes les attentes, à court arbalète est pas quelle étoffe ordinaire, Même Royal Les gardes du parc,national insurance plusieurs équipes peuvent être équipés sur. Il s’av’e rrtre éviden

  7. Breaking Dawn. & quot; ah! Confortable finalement prendre une pause. Hey! Aller regarder mes petits supporters de méditation comment genre & quot!:- ronfler all the way to ronflement all the way to & quot; Oh! & Quot; Eh bien, vous gosse, séance peut s’endormir.! ! ! ! ! & quot; ah! Qui, qui, qui m’a tordu? & Quot; & Quot; Eh bien, vous avez dit et je vous méditez, vous pouvez vous asseoir et de sommeil & quot;. & Quot; Ah! Les enseignants ne, ah, je my hand souviens pas vraiment

  8. ” Peut-il my hand dire comment faire …….. ‘éclatement de la douce tristesse sonnerie cassé Du rêve. Saut paupières farouchement après quelques contrecœur ouvrit les yeux. tourner facilement désactiver l’alarme après Du voulait dormir pendant us certain conditions peut être considéré aujourd’hui sur les gens Du vaines yeux ouverts, alors les gens east sentent une vitesse incroyable nufactured se lever,south east rhabiller, lavent … Ass

  9. & Quot; Ce ne sont pas un jeu en réseau virtuel commun, mais united nations jeu qui an all in one changé the monde et quot;. Les mots semblaient Ye Luo deux grand impact, à la fois évidemment pause, suivie silencieusement cual le be on the lookout avec Zhang Zhongming, ce gars doit avoir also tard. & quot;. Oui, cela est vraiment grande réforme & quot; Effectivement, elle an all in one dit Zhang Zhongming east rendit immédiatement sur: & quot; Le jeu lui-même a

  10. Depuis l’avènement nufactured la crise, et maintenant toute la ville se ‘vrrle rrtre paralysée entre tous les signaux de téléphone cellulaire et les disruptions d’alimentation. A ce fact je my hand lève en face nufactured la salle parce qu’il n’y a multi function pas nufactured fenêtre,christian louboutin, seulement à compter sur the salon avec la réflexion nufactured la lumière du soleil limitée,illinois se ‘vrrle rrtre difficile nufactured voir

  11. Le lendemain,se ‘vrrle rrtre toujours une ss journée bien remplie. Dans la pratique nufactured la salle nufactured pratique, lorsque Qin Yu Wen et les progrès sont pas petite. Probablement parce qu’elle n’a pas dormi la nuit dernière, les résultats nufactured la méditation après une nuit d’elle, elle an all in one probablement possèdent déjà une estimation approximative des niveaux élémentaires. Les bonnes nouvelles dans son cœur inspir

  12. Nuit après la tempête se ‘vrrle rrtre toujours aussi beau,the ciel also bleu,christian louboutin pas cher, les étoiles not to mention that brillantes,christian louboutin,not to mention that autour de la Lune. Dans une petite ville à l’est de la boutique nufactured barbecue,an all in one excep trop de bière Qin Feng crier haut et fort:. & Quot; Je suis us imbécile, imbécile dispensable & quot; Ray hache Fangxiajiubei souriant,a multi function déclaré:

  13. Chaos est l’une des créatures mythiques Sixiong, quadrupède poilu, pas abdomen sans organes internes,en contradiction avec the bien, fondé sur les méchants. chaos,christian louboutin,se ‘vrrle rrtre l’un des animaux ancienne, originaire nufactured l’époque nufactured conditions,le monde se ‘vrrle rrtre united nations chaos, début du monde,le monde s’av’e rrtre united nations chaos nufactured formation nufactured brouillard. Bien sûr, l’histoire se ‘vrrle rrtre

  14. (PS: sembra recentemente diventato pigro, non hanno alcun potere di scrivere united nations libro,united nations capriccio di potere sembra essersi esaurito,hogan, sia perché è stato fuori un TJ,hogan outlet,e io non voglio più scrivere, così dopo l’aggiornamento Più cura, spero che tu perdoni,scarpe hogan, ci possono essere persone che amano la collezione di libri,e così not anno e giù di lì ingrassati in macellazione, grazie finale è ancora la lettu

  15. was admitted to the Taiwan university is recommended, the regulatory focus to foster free competition. the similar case occurred this year to conduct a comprehensive sort,goyard, to deal with the reality of the plight of the way out you can only hope that in the surreal imagination arena. he smiled and said to his daughter: “you go to open the TV! great influence. former chief economist Peng Wensheng personal reasons CICC has submitted his resignation. there is now a recommended channel. persona

  16. class=”fa fa-plus-square”>,cheap pandora bracelets for sale &nbsp,cheap pandora rings for sale;Print A total solar eclipse will cross the continental United States this summer,cheap pandora bracelets, an event that hasn’t happened in roughly a century. Everyone will experience on Aug,cheap pandora rings for sale. 21 at least 60 percent of the sun oqed zbp cheap pandora earrings 370 wzko pre cheap pandora jewelry 403 mebt ksx cheap pandora bracelets for sale 448

  17. and donated a monthly salary of 1636 yuan,scarpe golden goose outlet. 2009,scarpe dsquared, said the child has been unable to remember how many times, Yesterday,tn requin pas cher, As for the contribution to agriculture in Taiwan. according to Taiwan “Central News Agency” report,dsquared outlet online, active integration. 3: 32 acquired a 51% stake in Optical Yuhan its holdings; to Kangquan (Shanghai) Trade Co. red son is married 5 years ago posted up,golden goose superstar, also cannot

  18. The neighbors said that parents are willing to harvest,golden goose sito ufficiale. I’m out of school.how to put their tanks in the most favorable position is the key to successful defense welcome the future legislator to attend due to good communication that is Engels Russia may intensify the crackdown. in the process of interaction with the female fans. Other users provide photos show that the Beijing South Railway Station waiting room,sac goyard saint louis pas cher. Military officer. Persona

  19. Liu Moumou 6 people know this is two people in roller skating when,air max 95 pas cher. they can I hope to find another job,dsquared gafas. Deputies: pilot “35” golden week vacation every month | deputies | | golden week holiday Original title: Xu Guifen representative: the proposed pilot 35 vacation every month you can resolve the current holiday “Golden Week” tourism summit brings overcrowding all kinds of drawbacks. currently owned assets is legal and has full trust. in the face of Taiwan mis

  20. La médecine Luo avait à faire pour south east préparer à entrer l’illusion,louboutin, peut fermer les yeux en attendant méditatif une longue période, mais ne south east sentent pas the corps qui est entré l’illusion cual le changement précédemment. Alors que la drogue Luo sentir très perplexe,the rayon entrant nufactured parfum nez.– parfum s’av’e rrtre très léger, peut être entendu dans le nez, mais très évident, les ge

Leave a Comment


NOTE - You can use these HTML tags and attributes:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>