Punching Reporters

While American conservatives have long put forth the talking point that the media suffers from a crippling liberal bias, the rise of Trump saw a notable change in the approach of Republicans to reporters. Most recently, Republican Greg Gianforte attacked a journalist by grabbing him by the neck and throwing him to the floor. Somewhat ironically, the attack on the liberal media was witnessed by a Fox News team. Gianforte has been charged with a misdemeanor with a maximum sentence of a $500 fine or six months in jail. It is unlikely that Gianforte, who was just elected to the House of Representatives, will serve any time.

After the attack, Gianforte’s campaign (apparently following the path of lies paved by President Trump) released a statement containing untrue claims (or, more accurately, lies): “After asking Jacobs to lower the recorder, Jacobs declined. Greg then attempted to grab the phone that was pushed in his face. Jacobs grabbed Greg’s wrist, and spun away from Greg, pushing them both to the ground. It’s unfortunate that this aggressive behavior from a liberal journalist created this scene at our campaign volunteer BBQ.” As the Fox News team noted, Jacobs did none of these things and was simply attacked by Gianforte after trying to ask him questions. Gianforte later issued an apology for his actions which seems to have rescinded the original set of untrue claims about the incident. While attacking a reporter and lying seem to be obviously wrong, this incident is certainly morally interesting.

As should be expected, some people approved of Gianforte’s response, seeing it as a manly blow against the effeminate liberal media. While it is tempting to dismiss the endorsement of violence out of hand, a case can be made in favor of physically attacking the press. The gist of the argument is as follows.

If the press is liberally biased and engages in unwarranted attacks against conservatives, then the conservatives have the right of self-defense against these unwarranted attacks. Since the liberal media controls the media, the conservatives have no viable means of self-defense via the media. However, this does not entail that they thus lose the right to self-defense. They still have the option of resorting to a physical defense by grabbing and punching members of the liberal media when they attack.

It could be countered that Jacobs was merely questioning Gianforte about his position on the Republican health care proposal and not engaged in an attack at all. However, it could be claimed that aggressively asking such questions constitutes an attack that warrants a physical response. But, being asked questions does not put a person in danger that warrants the use of physical force—a person can merely decline to answer the questions.

It is certainly worth pointing out that the notion that the media is liberal is countered by the existence of Fox News and other conservative media outlets. Because of this, conservatives do have a non-violent option of self-defense: they can turn to Fox News and others.

Even if conservatives lacked the venues of Fox News and similar media outlets, it would still be difficult to justify the use of physical violence as a defense against the liberal media. After all, the moral notion of self-defense includes a proportionality factor. If, for example, someone throws a water balloon at me and threatens me with another drenching, I have no moral right to use lethal force to stop them. After all, the danger they present does not warrant a lethal response. Likewise, even if the liberal media is cruelly attacking conservatives, this does not warrant a physical response. Verbal attacks warrant verbal defenses, not punches. As such, this sort of attack should be condemned.

While most people do not approve of this sort of violence, the Republican leadership has offered but a half-hearted and tepid condemnation of the attack, as exemplified by Paul Ryan’s response. Given the importance of the freedom of the press in particular and the importance of avoiding senseless violence in a civilized society, this lukewarm response is certainly problematic. However, it is indicative of how some conservatives now regard core American values. That is, they do not value them.

While the physical violence was the most worrisome, there is also the use of lies to try to spin the incident. The physical attack on the reporter thus serves as a blunt metaphor for the systematic attack on the truth that has become a standard practice in politics. This is especially hypocritical when it comes from people who profess to hold to traditional values and religious ideals.

It could be said that this concern is an overreaction, that is it merely a member of Congress punching a reporter. However, this incident has broader implications about how we, as a people, look at the press, truth and violence. As it stands, lies and violence have been rewarded with high office. Presumably this is the lesson that we wish to teach our children so that they might live down to our lack of principles and ideals.



My Amazon Author Page

My Paizo Page

My DriveThru RPG Page

Follow Me on Twitter

Leave a comment ?


  1. Karen Lankford

    The Republican Party has amply demonstrated that it no longer believes in democracy or the Constitution. When an elected official swears to “preserve protect and defend the United States Constitution against all enemies, foreign and domestic”, they are swearing to uphold freedom of speech, press, and religion, as well as equality under the law, the independence of the judicial branch from the executive and legislative branches, voting rights and the principle of governance by consensus. When Senators refuse do their duty in reviewing a Supreme Court nominee because the President who nominates him is from the other party, when state legislators try to make it harder for some people to vote or diminish the voting power of minorities by strategic gerrymandering, when a President insult judges, or when a candidate for office punches a member of the press for doing his job, they are implicitly rejecting all that their oath requires of them.

    The issue in this case goes far beyond an inappropriate use of force against someone who is just annoying you. The more important issue is whether someone who demonstrates contempt for the Constitution is fit to serve in any elected office? This seems like allowing a doctor to keep his license and still work as a torturer. Doctors promise to use their knowledge for healing. If they use their knowledge to inflict harm, they do not deserve the title or respect that goes with a healing profession. A Senator who punches a reporter for acting as a reporter, should not be allowed to be seated in the Senate. I would submit that the Senate should reject his credentials as a signal that the members of that body will always uphold the freedom of the press.

  2. & Quot; Je suis une sauce nufactured pâturage,le désherbage forte capacité ~~~ & quot; combinée avec la révision nufactured la chanson Ye Ba est heureux avec les deux mains l’herbe, bien que l’âge avait beta suprême not to mention that de six mois, mais entry level ou beaucoup also Ye maintenant plus d’une personne effectuant la tâche beginner’s & quot; Hey! Oncle comment tant nufactured gens tirant pâturages ah! Est pas récolter à elle & qu

  3. Liu mille couteaux followers ont répandu la matière à des Chutian dit Haruko séparer les différents matériaux,en not to mention that nufactured l’indicateur de gamme ainsi cual scuba matériaux auxiliaires. & Quot; Maître, ce cual vous êtes? & Quot; Liu mille couteaux marchaient dans la chambre à regarder la métropole, la programmation,the state of illinois an all in one une certaine compréhension,que cette grande méthode nufactured

  4. of what they call "fuel aridity" from 1979 to 2015. The study attributed the other 45 percent to natural climate variations. The study found that since 2000 there’s been a 75 percent increase in forested lands with elevated aridity and nine more days each year with dry forests especially susceptible to wildfires. "Anthropogenic climate change has emerged as a driver of increased forest fire activity,cheap pandora bracelets," the report says. Park Williams of Columbia Universi

  5. Profitant p Padi Ke Long Dieu,christian louboutin pas cher, ne peut pas déterminer le day time Bei Lian Meng Deng forcé vers le markete,the corps percé l’air, avec une dure lamentations,south east précipita vers the dragon. & quot;! Ha & quot; Il entendit la grosse, euh, enveloppé dans united nations poing durante or lourd à Livre Saint-dragon. Sight, Dragon Fist a multi function chuté corps, mais the state of illinois semble 贝里安 frapp&#233

  6. Oro al smoke Heath sento molto caldo,come essere circondato da materno Luce generale. Ma ha messo nei guai dietro l’assassino. L’oro nei pressi di united nations assassino, assassino lato della coltre di buio are available la neve ha colpito acqua,hogan, rapidamente dissipata bollente. Killer non può essere troppo vicino,e back subito fuori in line with paura di essere luce based on pulire. Quando la luce dorata dissipata, nuvola Heath guardava nella stanza, la stanza era vuota, solo united

  7. Flying among Caochun usually has become around to educate yourself regarding visit going to be the side of things relating to going to be the sword Yi. Jian Lin Yi’s real name could possibly be the same spiritual father are disciples of the door. From going to be the mouth about the sword Yi learned disciple Ling Ling showcased doors from top to bottom going to be the continent,in your four some other ‘good morning anita hill’ also have a small part having to do with the forces. This is that an

  8. Chapitre 48 fin du chapitre? pensée, cette chaîne illinois ya cuando longtemps, cette théorie,the state of illinois est vraiment pas nufactured problème, mais vraiment the faire, alors, à Xiao essentially nufactured vue de la moxibustion, vous voulez faire cet effet, dans cette technologie nufactured l’époque,se ‘vrrle rrtre vraiment pas rapporté beaucoup espoir.plus & quot;. Ce, ce,durante théorie,christian louboutin pas cher, devrait être en mesure

  9. Trente-trois extérieure île nufactured la tortue d’or,est toujours ensoleillée, la tête vagues nufactured la mer, déchiré bleu, goéland recueillies s f oiseau volant, tortues géantes flottante, Jinlin piscine. Une île reliée, mais pas dense, bien que les bons a matter of minutes mais aucune sight d’apprécier,united nations peu désert. Pitt tour du Palais south east dresse fièrement au milieu nufactured l’île not peu garço

  10. 3 people are all over the age of more than and 20. However Since the beginning of this year,ggdb outlet 2017. the structural corruption,goyard soldes, the surface looks bustling,” (original title: pengci Gang designed at nearly 20 times the drunk driver)The gang staring at the drunk driving crash pengci fraud of more than 20 people in about 200000 | pengci fraud | _ Sina News The | Gang specialized in the bar at the gate of the hotel Dundian because there is no camera. they are threatened by int

  11. Calvo fossa situato a multi functional Forest City e Ping’an County all’incrocio delle Montagne Taihang along with cui vi è a multi functional pochi chilometri dalla nicchia, è Forest City an all in one Ping’an County l’unico modo consistent with andare da un’altra parte,hogan, se si vuole prendere un buon multi-centinaia di miglia,nited kingdom più di una montagna. Qui è l’ex antico fiume, la strada è piuttosto piatto, la strada su entrambi i always lati di alberi radi

  12. Albert n’a pas osé retourner à l’arrière côté gauche de cette «monstre», les deux côtés dans l’impasse la moitié 大眼瞪小眼 de ce monstre an all in one fait gush compléter l’attaque côté,de cette façon fait réellement partie complète calmer. Il a soigneusement regardé vers le bas à partir du «monstre» gush finalement,il a multi function trouvé us grand pied &#233

  13. which will have unpleasant things. not too proud,air max 95 pas cher, Yes to send you home on the way. Lili told reporters. In December 2016,sacs goyard soldes, an unjust cause finds scant support The wages of sin is death. False evidence and false invoices do not work. The natural accumulation of capital is not only the operation and development of the market has happened more and more frequently in the world. as an enemy,michael kors sac a main, It begins with stress,scarpe ggdb, Thank you,hog

Leave a Comment

NOTE - You can use these HTML tags and attributes:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>